Public prototype · Fictional people and credits · 24-hour workspace
ReviewerBase

ReviewerBase · Shared infrastructure for peer review

Peer review is in danger.
Let’s fix it.

One shared reviewer network for journals and conferences across disciplines. Find experts, recognize reviewing, and let contributions count across venues with review credits.

We have built a working prototype. Explore how the idea works today and help shape the nonprofit infrastructure it could become.

01 / The problem

More papers. Too little time to review them.

Peer review depends on researchers contributing their expertise, yet that work often goes unrecognized. Review requests pile up, and editors struggle to find people with the right expertise and time to help.

At the same time, low-quality submissions aggravate the problem. AI makes them easier to produce at scale, while incentives still encourage authors to maximize their output. Reviewers face more work without a corresponding reward.

Authors pay the price too: long waits and rushed reviews undermine useful feedback and fair decisions. We need a better balance between submitting research and reviewing it.

02 / Our proposal

Share the reviewer pool. Choose how to participate.

One shared reviewer network

Help journals and conferences find suitable researchers through their expertise, publications and reviewing preferences. Researchers should control their participation and how they can be contacted.

The prototype connects manuscript-based reviewer discovery, publication evidence and private reviewer lists. The different services are independently usable.

Credits for reviews and submissions

Participating venues confirm completed reviews and award credits. Researchers can use those credits for submissions at other participating journals and conferences. A credit counts equally wherever it was earned.

Each venue sets its own submission requirements. The aim is to recognize reviewing while giving authors a reason to be selective about what they submit. Try review awards, submission-credit requests and waivers in the prototype.

The intended effect: more reviewing, fewer low-quality submissions, and more time for careful, substantive feedback. Whether this works in practice needs to be evaluated with participating researchers and venues.

03 / Expected benefits

For journals & conferences

  • Find relevant expertise beyond your existing reviewer list.
  • Inspect linked publications and keep useful contacts in a private pool.
  • Recognize completed reviews through a shared workflow.
  • Use the credit system to encourage reviewing and more considered submissions.

For reviewers

  • Make your expertise and interest in reviewing visible to editors.
  • Choose whether to appear in discovery and share your account email.
  • Build a record of confirmed reviewing contributions.
  • Earn credits that can be used across participating venues.

For authors

  • A broader reviewer pool means shorter waits and better-matched feedback.
  • Your own reviewing can support your future submissions.
  • Contributions count beyond a single journal or conference.
  • Waivers provide a fair route for people with limited review opportunities.

04 / Conditions for this to work

Connected, fair and accountable.

Connect existing systems

We will provide ORCID and editorial-platform integrations to reduce repeated data entry. The prototype already supports optional ORCID lookup and a completion API; broader integrations and shared invitation handling are still ahead.

Design against abuse and exclusion

Confirm genuine reviews, prevent duplicate rewards and govern credit issuance. Protect confidential information and make participation possible for newcomers. The prototype demonstrates confirmation records, duplicate checks and waivers; pilot participants still need to agree on operating policies and fair entry routes.

Keep it nonprofit and community-governed

ReviewerBase will serve scholarship, with transparent rules and oversight that keep control out of the hands of a single publisher or commercial owner. Building that governance, alongside a sustainable service, is part of the work ahead.

05 / FAQ

Before you take part.

The prototype lets you test concrete workflows. Detailed policies for a live service remain open for discussion with researchers and pilot venues.

Can a venue join without using credits?

Yes. Reviewer discovery and private reviewer lists are useful on their own. Credits are optional, and journals and conferences keep control over their editorial policies and existing submission systems.

Why not pay reviewers directly?

Monetary payments are not ruled out. Our infrastructure might provide a good foundation for them later, but sustainable funding and incentives against gaming need careful design. Payments are not part of the current prototype; credits have no monetary value.

What if I have not had opportunities to review?

Lack of credits should not exclude newcomers or researchers with limited review opportunities. The prototype provides starting credits and demonstrates waiver requests. At the same time, our reviewer search algorithm ensures that early-career researchers become visible to editors.

Who confirms that a review was completed?

An authorized journal or conference representative records completion under its published rules. The prototype supports manual confirmation and API completion receipts, while preventing duplicate rewards. Confirmation establishes that work took place; it is not an assessment of scientific quality.

How do you discourage low-quality reviews submitted just for credits?

Editors can record a private quality rating when acknowledging a review. The prototype keeps this within the journal and does not make it public. Also, our reviewer search algorithm prefers to recommend reviewers with a record of high-quality reviews. If reviewers want to earn credits long-term, they have to submit high-quality reviews.

How can reviewers be contacted?

In the prototype, authorized editors can see contact details that a researcher has chosen to share, or save a journal-private contact. Invitations and review reports stay in the journal’s existing systems. Long-term, we want to enable reviewers to fully control their review invitations, e.g. "maximum 3 reviews per month".

Who can see my information?

Researchers choose whether they appear in discovery, share their account email or restrict discovery to nonprofit venues. Journals’ contact lists and review-quality ratings are private. Personal credit history is available to its account holder. The long-term vision is to give reviewers full control about who can see their data and contact them.

Is this a live service?

This is a working public prototype. You can explore reviewer discovery, award credits and follow submission-credit requests using sample accounts. It does not send real invitations or emails, and journal verification is simulated. Trial data expires after 24 hours or when you reset the demo. The reviewer search is functional but does not show email addresses for potential reviewers.

06 / Contact

Help shape what comes next.

We have moved from an idea to a working prototype, and are looking for researchers and venues to try it, challenge the assumptions, and fix our reviewing system together.

07 / Newsletter

Stay up to date with ReviewerBase.

Get project news as the prototype develops. Only your email address is required, and subscribing does not commit you to taking part. If you’d like, you can also tell us about your interests in feedback or a future pilot.

Tell us a little more (optional)
You can also contact me about (optional)

08 / Try the demo

Explore the working prototype.

No registration needed. Start with a sample account and switch perspectives using the demonstration toolbar.

For journal and conference editors

Find suitable reviewers for a manuscript, inspect publication evidence, save private contacts and recognize completed reviews with credits.

For researchers

Present your expertise, choose your discovery preferences, inspect earned credits and follow a submission-credit request or ask for a waiver.

ReviewerBase · An OpenScientia ServicePrivacyIndependent journals. Shared recognition.